Another argument used to justify the effort to legalize same-sex marriage is the argument from humanism. It is stated that without state licensed marriage, same-sex couples are doomed to a life of loneliness. The argument would be something like this:
P1: Marriage is necessary for loving, intimate, fulfilling relationships
P2: Same-Sex couples also want loving, intimate, fulfilling relationships
C1: Same-Sex marriage should be legalized
The response is that loving, intimate, fulfilling relationships do not require a government license. Same-sex couples could have just such a relationship, whether the government licenses their relationship and calls it a marriage or not.
Continue reading at the original source →